Written by Terri Reddout
Do men and women communicate differently?
YES, THEY DO!
Experts researched how men and women communicate and found there are many differences between the genders. Now, these differences don’t apply to everyone but they do represents some generalities in the way each gender approaches communication.
Our friends from the TV show Friends give us an excellent example.
As Phoebe, Rachel and Monica demonstrated, females tend to focus on details, the emotions, the thought process. As Chandler, Joey and Ross showed us, males tend to focus on facts. It’s just one of the many differences in gender communication styles. Understanding these differences will make communicating with the opposite gender a lot easier and more effective (and make you popular with the other gender.)
Casey & Kate: Problem solving versus working through the problem
This is a picture of my son Casey and the love of his life, Kate. When Kate and I first met, she thanked me. She said she appreciated the fact that I taught Casey to listen to a woman rather than immediately trying to solve the woman’s problem.
This represents several differences between the genders we identify with.
Males are more autonomous. Males tend to work problems out on their own. They think it through and come up with a solution and they are done. Finished.
Females tend to think through their problems aloud. They need to hear themselves describe the problem. They are interested in other people’s feedback. Sometimes they have a solution in mind, but they need to vent.
So, if when a female decides to share a problem with a male, the male’s first instinct is to solve the problem. When the male offers a solution the female is baffled. That’s not what she was asking for. He hasn’t even heard her describe the entire problem. Now she’s perturbed because the male wasn’t listening to her. And the male is confused because his solution would obviously solve the problem; end of discussion.
When Kate vents my son says the solution to her problem still jumps into his head. But he identifies it as a communication noise, pushes it aside and turns his attention toward listening. If it turns out Kate just needs to vent, then he’s done his job (and he is a hero). If he thinks Kate seriously wants to hear his ideas, Casey says he’ll wait until she asks. (BTW- You’re welcome, Kate!)
Okay, this video is a bit over the top, but it’s an example of what females want versus what males think the problem is.
Honey, what are you thinking about?
On the flip side of this, females will ask a male “What are you thinking?” The answer they often get is “Nothing.” As we learned from Rachel, Phoebe and Monica, females want details. So, when they hear “Nothing” they feel as if you don’t want to share and there’s got to be a reason why you don’t want to share.
From the males prospective, they may seriously may have been thinking about nothing. Or, at least what they consider nothing. They may have been thinking about buying a new car, but they are more focused on the facts: gas mileage, horsepower, number of seats, etc. There’s nothing really unusual about this so it’s “nothing.”
What the experts say…
Overall, researchers say females value communication, connection and building relationships. Males value independence, power and status. One set of skills or approaches to communication aren’t necessarily better than the other… just different.
Not all of these characteristics apply to all members of the gender. They are just generalities. In some cases, I may communicate in a more female fashion but in another situation I would use a more direct, male approach.
Males can learn from females how to better tune into what the other person is saying so you can get a better picture of what’s going on. In essence, reading between the lines.
Females can learn from males to be more direct. No explanation necessary.
Over the years, I’ve learned that when a male asks me a question I should probably answer different than when a female asks me. For example, if my brother asks me about my trip to see my son, he’s interested in if I had any car problems, how long it took me and how much time I got to spend with Casey. If he wants to know something more, he’ll ask.
If my sister asks the same question I’m going to tell her about how I listened to Bruno Mars all the way to Portland, how delicious the waffles were at the Waffle Window, what Casey and I talked about on the drive to the park and do I still think Kate is awesome. (BTW- Kate is awesome.)
Below is a chart of the differences the experts identified between males and females.
|Seek out relationships with others||Tend to seek standing & position|
|Relate to others as equals||Relate to others as rivals|
|Prefer interdependency, collaboration, coordination and cooperation||Tend toward independence and autonomy|
|Make decisions based on mutual agreement||Choose or resolve by force, persuasion or majority rule|
|Desire closeness, togetherness and affinity||Desires space|
|Care for the approval of peers||Tend to seek the respect of peers|
|Express themselves more in public||Express themselves more in private|
|More open to share problems||Keep concerns to themselves|
|Tend to focus on details of emotions||Tend to focus on the details of fact|
|Tend to ask for help, advice, directions||Often will not ask for advice, help or directions|
|Offer sympathy, Display empathy||Freely offer advice and analysis|
|Desire to understand problems||Are problem solvers|
|Tend to take a more sober look at challenges||Tend to look at challenges as a game unless life and death is at stake|
|Listen more||Talk more|
|Make more eye contact||Sees eye contact as a challenge to power|
We’re going to explain ourselves to the opposite gender in our Explain it to me: Gender Com Discussion Group. Type up a post that addresses the following:
- Identify yourself by the gender you most closely associate.
- Select a characteristic from your gender’s column and describe it to the opposite gender. Explain what’s good about it. Then describe its limitations.
- Then select a characteristic from the opposite gender’s column and share your perception or ask questions of the opposite gender.
- Posts and comments on the discussion board will be evaluated. You are welcome to post comments to this blog, but they won’t be considered for a grade.
See Canvas for the date and time your post is due. See Canvas for when your comments are due. This assignment is worth 25 points (20 points for post/5 points for comments.)
- 10 points for describing your gender’s characteristic and providing an example.
- 10 points for sharing your perception of the other gender’s characteristic, providing an example and/or asking questions
- 5 points for commenting on at least 3 other students’ posts.